Throughout this semester, we have discussed several practical digital methods to make data visualization more accessible to greater audiences using timelines, charts, networks, maps, three-dimensional modeling, and more comprehensive, freely available metadata. This past week, we analyzed how crowdsourcing, volunteer, and collaborative-centered processes can be positive ways in which institutions enact these digital methods.
One of the biggest crowdsourced resources available thanks to the advent of the Internet is Wikipedia. Wikipedia allows any user to freely edit and create Wikipedia pages while editors ensure that information is accurate with appropriate references. This framework is not perfect, though. Incorrect or biased information may escape editors’ notice just as much as honest information may be deleted or flagged as plagiarism. The overwhelming use of Wikipedia for daily reference by people worldwide, however, still makes it an incredibly powerful resource and useful for institutions that want to provide the best information about their collections.

GLAMwiki Heading, screenshot from Wikipedia site, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:GLAM/Contribute.
GLAMwiki is an initiative by Wikipedia focusing on galleries, libraries, archives, and museums. It allows these institutions to create projects for pages that they would like to be created or updated. These projects are collaborative and provide editors with a specific collection or pages to begin editing. Institutions like the Smithsonian Archives of American Art and the British Museum have even had designated “Wikipedians in Residence” to either work directly with curators and museum experts to accurately convey information about their collections or by piloting community-based “edit-a-thon” events. The goal of GLAMwiki projects is to accurately inform Wikipedia users about objects in their collections, not as a promotional tool for the museum itself—although increased traffic to an institutions’ own website may be an added benefit. GLAMwiki utilizes the same collaborative, low-cost, crowdsourced framework as Wikipedia in general, but focuses particularly on these collections-based institutions.
Edit-a-thon events can be particularly helpful for institutions not only as a low-cost initiative to produce accurate information about their collections but also to include editors with diverse perspectives into this knowledge production process. The Art + Feminism initiative sponsored edit-a-thon events to increase representation of women in Wikipedia pages. Institutions may host edit-a-thon events as a form of community engagement, allowing people with different perspectives to come together in a physical space to share research and information. These edit-a-thons may focus on a single collection or a broader effort, like creating and updating more pages related to marginalized people like women, queer people, or racially diverse groups.
Jessica BrodeFrank writes in “Crowdsourcing Metadata in Museums: Expanding Descriptions, Access, Transparency, and Experience” that crowdsourcing can produce a sense of community and ownership over the metadata and collections in a museum. Crowdsourcing gives the communities that museums serve the opportunity to contribute to the production of metadata. BrodeFrank uses the Adler Planetarium project Tag Along with the Adler as a case study to examine this crowdsourced approach in action. The project used another crowdsourcing recruitment site, Zooniverse, to practically implement the program. A survey that BrodeFrank conducted indicated that the majority of participants were white, female, and under 30 with the most participants still in middle and high school. While crowdsourcing the metadata tagging sought to diversify the perspectives contributing to its metadata, it was still found that the majority of participants were white while the integration of the project into middle and high school classrooms suggests a reason for the young ages of the participants.
I think that it would be worth it for any small cultural institution or museum to create a GLAMwiki project simply to extend research and visibility of an institution beyond a likely small staff. Organizations like the Pennsylvania German Cultural Heritage Center in Kutztown, Pennsylvania or the Preservation Society of Newport County in Rhode Island would stand to benefit from creating a GLAMwiki project. I use these two examples simply because I have interned with them in the past, but I believe that this could be applied to any other small, local institutions. I am not sure if there are certain requirements that must be met to be added to the list of GLAMwiki projects. I could envision that there may be certain requirements that these small institutions may not be able to meet, but I believe that creating a crowdsourced project may help these institutions inform a broader public about their collections.
Museum Fun: Games and Humor
The museum’s primary objective since its inception is to educate and provide a space where its visitors can contemplate, reflect, and learn about the art, objects, or artifacts that it displays. Since Enlightenment and nationalist efforts of the late eighteenth to nineteenth centuries that established museums to create educated citizens, people began to treat the museum as a leisure activity. In the 21st century, museums’ challenge is to find a balance between leisure and accessible education without confining the museum to another form of entertainment in the modern attention economy. Despite a desire not to be just another contributor to the attention economy void, it is also important for museums and cultural institutions to not take themselves so seriously that it alienates them from broader society. The goal of the museum should be to connect to a wide audience, not just academics or museum professionals.

Screenshot of Anthropeum Game, https://anthropeum.com/.
The most successful museum “games” or educational programming are those that invite close-looking or segue neatly into formal analysis. A person does not need to be a student or expert of art history to look closely. This may be as simple as a scavenger hunt in the museum or an interactive tour where a docent asks visitors to describe the art in front of them. Virtual games are also a beneficial way to connect with an audience outside of the museum space. Activities like Anthropeum’s time period and geographical guessing game is an especially great example of a game that is both fun and informative, although it does require some knowledge of art and art history to play successfully. During our discussion after playing the Google Arts and Culture games, we determined that the most engaging games had scoring systems, virtually recreated an artistic process, and interacted with the art beyond superficially including it as an image with a caption. Games have the potential to be fun, engage visitors, and encourage close-looking, but they should be thoughtfully implemented to successfully enhance visitor understanding rather than be a distraction.









