Beyond the Women's Building

Women Architects and World Fairs

Crowdsourcing and Games in the Museum

Throughout this semester, we have discussed several practical digital methods to make data visualization more accessible to greater audiences using timelines, charts, networks, maps, three-dimensional modeling, and more comprehensive, freely available metadata. This past week, we analyzed how crowdsourcing, volunteer, and collaborative-centered processes can be positive ways in which institutions enact these digital methods.

            One of the biggest crowdsourced resources available thanks to the advent of the Internet is Wikipedia. Wikipedia allows any user to freely edit and create Wikipedia pages while editors ensure that information is accurate with appropriate references. This framework is not perfect, though. Incorrect or biased information may escape editors’ notice just as much as honest information may be deleted or flagged as plagiarism. The overwhelming use of Wikipedia for daily reference by people worldwide, however, still makes it an incredibly powerful resource and useful for institutions that want to provide the best information about their collections.

GLAMwiki Heading, screenshot from Wikipedia site, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:GLAM/Contribute.

GLAMwiki is an initiative by Wikipedia focusing on galleries, libraries, archives, and museums. It allows these institutions to create projects for pages that they would like to be created or updated. These projects are collaborative and provide editors with a specific collection or pages to begin editing. Institutions like the Smithsonian Archives of American Art and the British Museum have even had designated “Wikipedians in Residence” to either work directly with curators and museum experts to accurately convey information about their collections or by piloting community-based “edit-a-thon” events. The goal of GLAMwiki projects is to accurately inform Wikipedia users about objects in their collections, not as a promotional tool for the museum itself—although increased traffic to an institutions’ own website may be an added benefit. GLAMwiki utilizes the same collaborative, low-cost, crowdsourced framework as Wikipedia in general, but focuses particularly on these collections-based institutions.

Edit-a-thon events can be particularly helpful for institutions not only as a low-cost initiative to produce accurate information about their collections but also to include editors with diverse perspectives into this knowledge production process.  The Art + Feminism initiative sponsored edit-a-thon events to increase representation of women in Wikipedia pages. Institutions may host edit-a-thon events as a form of community engagement, allowing people with different perspectives to come together in a physical space to share research and information. These edit-a-thons may focus on a single collection or a broader effort, like creating and updating more pages related to marginalized people like women, queer people, or racially diverse groups.

Jessica BrodeFrank writes in “Crowdsourcing Metadata in Museums: Expanding Descriptions, Access, Transparency, and Experience” that crowdsourcing can produce a sense of community and ownership over the metadata and collections in a museum. Crowdsourcing gives the communities that museums serve the opportunity to contribute to the production of metadata. BrodeFrank uses the Adler Planetarium project Tag Along with the Adler as a case study to examine this crowdsourced approach in action. The project used another crowdsourcing recruitment site, Zooniverse, to practically implement the program. A survey that BrodeFrank conducted indicated that the majority of participants were white, female, and under 30 with the most participants still in middle and high school. While crowdsourcing the metadata tagging sought to diversify the perspectives contributing to its metadata, it was still found that the majority of participants were white while the integration of the project into middle and high school classrooms suggests a reason for the young ages of the participants.

I think that it would be worth it for any small cultural institution or museum to create a GLAMwiki project simply to extend research and visibility of an institution beyond a likely small staff.  Organizations like the Pennsylvania German Cultural Heritage Center in Kutztown, Pennsylvania or the Preservation Society of Newport County in Rhode Island would stand to benefit from creating a GLAMwiki project. I use these two examples simply because I have interned with them in the past, but I believe that this could be applied to any other small, local institutions. I am not sure if there are certain requirements that must be met to be added to the list of GLAMwiki projects. I could envision that there may be certain requirements that these small institutions may not be able to meet, but I believe that creating a crowdsourced project may help these institutions inform a broader public about their collections.

Museum Fun: Games and Humor

The museum’s primary objective since its inception is to educate and provide a space where its visitors can contemplate, reflect, and learn about the art, objects, or artifacts that it displays. Since Enlightenment and nationalist efforts of the late eighteenth to nineteenth centuries that established museums to create educated citizens, people began to treat the museum as a leisure activity. In the 21st century, museums’ challenge is to find a balance between leisure and accessible education without confining the museum to another form of entertainment in the modern attention economy. Despite a desire not to be just another contributor to the attention economy void, it is also important for museums and cultural institutions to not take themselves so seriously that it alienates them from broader society. The goal of the museum should be to connect to a wide audience, not just academics or museum professionals.

Screenshot of Anthropeum Game, https://anthropeum.com/.

The most successful museum “games” or educational programming are those that invite close-looking or segue neatly into formal analysis. A person does not need to be a student or expert of art history to look closely. This may be as simple as a scavenger hunt in the museum or an interactive tour where a docent asks visitors to describe the art in front of them. Virtual games are also a beneficial way to connect with an audience outside of the museum space. Activities like Anthropeum’s time period and geographical guessing game is an especially great example of a game that is both fun and informative, although it does require some knowledge of art and art history to play successfully. During our discussion after playing the Google Arts and Culture games, we determined that the most engaging games had scoring systems, virtually recreated an artistic process, and interacted with the art beyond superficially including it as an image with a caption. Games have the potential to be fun, engage visitors, and encourage close-looking, but they should be thoughtfully implemented to successfully enhance visitor understanding rather than be a distraction.

Immersive Facsimiles as a Form of Play

This is the probably unit of the class I was the most excited about! I am very familiar with 3D modeling on the arts production side, but I had never had the chance to approach it from an art historical or pedagogical perspective. In particular, I was not familiar with embodiment theory; I was operating on a much more vibes-based understanding of what makes art immersive that’s informed by my own trial and error in creating immersive environments. Sarah Kenderdine’s article “Embodiment, Entanglement, and Immersion in Digital Cultural Heritage” explores some of what it means in a more philosophical sense to build a multisensory, non-static, kinesthetic representation of works of art. Part of Kenderdine’s argument is that these types of environments allow for a higher level of learning and emotional connection for students who are able to use these tools. 

I think this builds on some interesting conversations about surrogacy that we’ve touched on over the course of the class. Namely, is there a way to create a facsimile that comes close to replicating the experience of the original work? While I think virtual reality and 3D models are incredible technological marvels (I was, in fact, prepared to devote my life to making them before realizing the work available to me was car insurance commercials and unpaid indie films), I’m not sure that they’re the real, true answer to that question. However, that does not necessarily render them useless. A theme I’ve been thinking on throughout the class is the space Kenderdine describes as “the borderline of the indexically real and the phantasmally virtual – between re‐embodiment and dis‐embodiment.” We all understand, on a fundamental level, that facsimiles are not real. I don’t think there is a way to capture the true aura of an original object, and yet, that has never once stopped anyone from trying to share their experience of that aura. Surrogates then end up existing in the space between truth and performance, never really able to lean into one side or the other. I don’t think we can start to have effective 3D and immersive surrogates unless we start explicitly breaking that kayfabe and being intentional about embracing the places where these methods fall short of reality.

If the ultimate goal of making an immersive environment or 3D digital representation of an object is to offer the opportunity to advance scholarship and investment in specific works or sites, as antithetical as it sounds, I don’t think you can neglect spectacle. Something my former professor Stuart Robertson said once really stuck with me, and even if it’s not necessarily a 1:1 analogy in this case, stick with me. In Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight, it was decided that they’d be flipping an 18-wheeler on set rather than rendering it in post production, where it would have been cheaper, safer, and still gotten the point across. But, you can bet that every person who was on set that day they flipped the truck walked away telling that story for years afterwards. Sometimes, you just have to do things because they’re cool! And while that is an interesting moment in cinema history, it certainly didn’t detract from the story that was being told; if you bring up The Dark Knight to someone, they’re much more likely to acknowledge the performances in the film than the truck flip. To that end, wonder and awe can have a place in pedagogy, and that doesn’t necessarily mean that the substantive intellectual content you’re leading them to is cheapened. If the gimmick truly supports the narrative you are trying to tell and gets more people to engage with something they may not have before, it is worth doing.


It was exciting for me to get back into photogrammetry during this week! One of my mentors at SCAD wrote his thesis on incorporating photogrammetry into visual effects curriculums, and a few of my classmates and I got to help start up a photogrammetry club at the school. While the technology has been around for a while, as a 21 year old in 2018 it seemed like it was magic! I was also fortunate enough to be in lovely Savannah as I was learning, which has some incredible architecture that was relatively easy to capture. Although I never finished this project, here’s a screenshot of a model I created depicting a set of stairs down to River Street that my friends and I called “The Bachelorette Killer.” 

And here’s a turnaround of an unpatched model of my friend’s plushie that I included in my demo reel.

We got to generate the beginnings of a model in our workshop, and I’ll admit I was surprised how well it worked with only 12 images! Typically, we recommended 30-80 photos in our workshops, but that many high-resolution photos would have made this short workshop take much, much longer.

I’d also like to point out something that you may not know if you haven’t ever 3D modeled before. Take a look at the wireframe for the model, and take a look at how many faces it has.

For any kind of practical purpose, this is not best practice. In order to make models created with photogrammetry usable in production without ballooning your render time (or slowing down your real-time viewer), you’d need to decimate and retopologize this model. Without getting too much into the weeds of 3D modeling workflows, this means that you redraw the faces in a more logical way that does not remove detail from the model itself. Here’s an image that shows what exactly retopologizing looks like- notice how the detail of the form is not being lost, but the wireframe looks like something you can understand. 

For our purposes in this class, retopologizing is not a pressing issue- I only bring it up because if you want to create a model that you want people to actually use, reuse, and distribute, you will need to take steps to prevent it from lagging people’s computers and browsers.

Kenderdine, Sarah. “Embodiment, Entanglement, and Immersion in Digital Cultural Heritage.” In A New Companion to Digital Humanities, 1st ed., edited by Susan Schreibman, Ray Siemens, and John Unsworth. Wiley, 2015. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118680605.ch2.

Mental Maps and Spaghetti Globes: showing connection effectively

Although our focus as a class was on network analysis as a product and process of research, it seemed like many of our discussions took us into the realm of user experience design. Network analysis can be complicated (and is very easily overcomplicated), and the effective illustration of networks seems to be the true test of not only the clarity of the research, but a solid understanding of how it could be used. 

In the 2022 article “Perceptual Effects of Hierarchy in Art Historical Social Networks” by Lamqaddam, De Prekel, Brosens, and Verbert, network graphs were stress tested by graduate students in order to measure their efficacy as tools for communication. Lamqaddam et al. really dug into why we organize connections the way that we do, and how we can create clear maps that allow for hierarchy but do not limit relationships to being hierarchical. They considered where the differences lie between mental maps and physical ones, and asked both where that clarity was being lost and how they could incorporate it back in. The branching family tree style network has such a strong cultural hold on how hierarchical relationships are understood that drastic deviations from this organizational structure increased levels of frustration and decreased levels of confidence in the viewers’ understanding of the material. 

This article resonated with me, because as someone who has not yet had the chance to use network graphs in my academic career, I find myself getting a bit lost in the “spaghetti globe” (as Dr. Bauer put it) without feeling fully convinced that it brings any additional clarity or insight into research. While I never had the opportunity to take UX design classes in my undergraduate program, I had friends and roommates who did and I helped blind-test their designs by showing them how I would navigate them. I will never forget the dawning realizations on their faces when the structures that made complete sense to them weren’t particularly clear to me (or to their other testers), and I’ve noticed that same dissonance between how a project is designed to be used and how it actually appears to its users in a few of the projects we’ve looked at for this class.

Network analysis also seems to highlight some of the underlying inadequacies of representing complex information with a flattened set of data. For instance, in Lozana Rossenova and Karen Di Franco’s article “Iterative Pasts and Linked Futures,” Carolee Schneemann’s Parts of a Body House is used as an example of an open-ended network mapping success. The nature of artist’s book publishing places works such as this one in a uniquely situated web of connections; several iterations of the same content have been published in different literary forms, and despite being catalogued, archives, libraries, and museums have no universal standardized way to indicate the presence of text from this work. For instance, Parts of a Body House was also partially published in several magazines, but because of the nature of cataloguing, Schneemann is not indexed as being a part of those publications and therefore it would be difficult to locate versions of this text across multiple institutions. 

When we were playing with Kumu as a class to map the people involved with Dancing with the Stars, we got to see how difficult it is to map some of those multiplicities. What we started with was straightforward: add contestants, judges, and pro dancers and connect them to their roles. What we ended up with was something that still needed some work to become legible. Here is our map as we left it in class.

And here it is with a little cleanup. Hopefully the interactable map loads okay.

iframe[src*="kumu.io"] { height: 750px !important; min-height: 750px !important; }

I felt like surely the first iteration was not the intended final product, so I messed around in the settings a little. Forgive me, I know it was a collaborative project! All I did was un-pin all of the nodes and let Kumu do its default force-directed organization. It’s a lot more legible, but you can more clearly see now where we were still working on adding in connections and building new types of connections. For instance, one type of connection my classmates hoped to add was married couples. In Kumu you can connect any nodes to one another, but in order to define that relationship you have to annotate that connection. This makes it very difficult to build a network at a larger scale; sure, we were able to reasonably begin a network of a few dozen people, but what happens when you want to map hundreds or thousands of connections? Network analysis is, after all, intended to facilitate macroanalysis. It is not an impossible task by any means, but it seems like a difficult one to scale that gives diminishing returns on clarity.

Of course, social networks are not the only thing you can map; we also took a look at the tool ORBIS, which honestly answers a lot of my qualms about network mapping as a research product. ORBIS, which is a project mapping the transportation network of the Roman Empire organized by Stanford, bills itself as an “interactive scholarly work.” While there is a distinct difference between networks mapped as a research method vs networks mapped as a product of research, ORBIS seems to somehow be both. I’m not particularly an expert in the Roman Empire (I took my first survey of art history course over ten years ago and only studied contemporary art after that), but even I could see how valuable of a tool this could be for a number of audiences.

ORBIS charting a path from Londinium to Alexandria in the Summer.

I think ORBIS is a particularly effective example of network analysis because it has a clear visual goal based on connections in a framework we can understand and has ample documentation of how to use the tool itself, which really embodies that goal of being an interactive scholarly work. Having the scholarly work is one thing, but as I mentioned before, It’s not worth much as an expression of information if no one can read, understand, or use it.

Iterative Pasts and Linked Futures: A Feminist Approach to Modeling Data in Archives and Collections of Artists’ Publishing. December 19, 2022. https://www.artic.edu/digital-publications/37/perspectives-on-data/28/iterative-pasts-and-linked-futures-a-feminist-approach-to-modeling-data-in-archives-and-collections-of-artists-publishing.

Lamqaddam, Houda, Inez De Prekel, Koenraad Brosens, and Katrien Verbert. “Perceptual Effects of Hierarchy in Art Historical Social Networks.” Digital Humanities Quarterly 016, no. 1 (2022).

“Modeling Networks and Scholarship with ORBIS · Journal of Digital Humanities.” Accessed October 26, 2026. https://journalofdigitalhumanities.org/1-3/modeling-networks-and-scholarship-with-orbis-by-elijah-meeks-and-karl-grossner/.

3D Modeling: A New Frontier in the Field of Digital Art History

Three-dimensional modeling is a relatively recent addition to the field of digital art history that include a range of experiences like creating facsimiles of objects or mirroring embodied experiences with virtual reality. Amy Jeffs and Sarah Kenderdine explain these new frontiers in their respective articles, “Digital 3D Modeling for the History of Art” and “Embodiment, Entanglement, and Immersion in Digital Cultural Heritage.”  Three-dimensional models are also a fun and interactive method of displaying objects in a collection, which we can see in the Smithsonian’s X3D collection. Finally, I learned how to create these digital three-dimensional models using photogrammetry with the platforms AgiSoft and Sketchfab.

Beyond being a more interesting method to interact with digital objects in a collection, three-dimensional models also provide greater access to an object. In class, we looked at at an Apollo 11 space suit in the Smithsonian Museum’s X3D collection. The viewer can look at the suit from all different angles, including areas concealed in a typical gallery exhibit. For example, the user could manipulate the view of the model with the mouse to see the back of the suit and even the soles of the boots. It was also helpful to zoom in to read notes stitched into the arm of the spacesuit. In this sense, it gave the viewer greater access to the object than just a few standard photographs that museums typically use for their digital collections.

Jeffs expands on this idea that three-dimensional models can enhance art history education and object-based analysis. She uses the example of a project concerning the reproduction of miniature pilgrimage tokens to explain how the photogrammetric models can communicate important information about their production. The actual data required for photogrammetry, the geospatial data collected by the photographs required to perform photogrammetry, document important information that may be used to identify other historical works cast from the same model. Pedagogically, the reproduction of these tokens also recreates how they would be handled, touched, and experienced by medieval pilgrims—a beneficial, interactive educational experience.

The interactive New York Times article from 2018 written by Melena Ryzik exhibited some of David Bowie’s most memorable outfits using three-dimensional modeling. Ryzik and the producers’ effectively used three-dimensional modeling techniques to communicate to the viewer how these spectacular outfits would have fit Bowie. The 360-degree view of the outfit communicated a sense of embodiment beyond two-dimensional pictures in a catalogue. The viewer cannot interact with the three-dimensional model beyond the path of the article, however, meaning that the model can only be viewed within the prescribed path of rotation. The three-dimensional models included in this article are enhance the written content rather than be the entire focus of the article.

With the Smithsonian’s collection, the user could determine what view he or she wanted to see rather than accepting the model’s path of rotation as in the New York Times article. The article’s failure to make views of the model customizable may be credited to the amount of storage necessary to present such models. For the sake of the article, this more permanent rendering of the three-dimensional model is the most appropriate. For a museum, however, the Smithsonian’s format that allows the user to view objects from a variety of angles is more relevant to its purpose.

Kenderdine explores the concept of embodiment in three-dimensional models and virtual reality. While the New York Times article provides a good idea of how clothes would have looked, felt, and affected the movement of Bowie, Kenderdine thinks about virtual reality and panoramic views as a starting point for recreating embodied experiences. Unlike viewing digital three-dimensional objects in a collection, like the Smithson’s X3D collection, virtual reality and panoramas put the viewer in the center of the model. Kenderdine explains that this method of three-dimensional modeling has its roots in the cycloramas of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries depicting American Civil War battles. The Battle of Gettysburg Cyclorama, created by French artist Paul Philippoteaux in 1884, is an example of this antiquated entertainment still on view at the Gettysburg Foundation Museum. This cyclorama places the viewer in the center of the action, allowing him or her to explore the full circle of the painting.

Two images depicting visitors viewing the Gettysburg Cyclorama by Paul Philippoteaux, 1884. Gettysburg Foundation.

Beyond the cycloramas of the late nineteenth centuries, Kenderdine includes virtual reality as a new frontier for recreating embodied experiences in art history and museum exhibitions. Kenderdine uses the example of the exhibition Pure Land: Inside the Mogao Grottoes to explain an effective harmony of multiple digital reproductive methods to create a multi-sensory visitor experience that enhances the viewer’s understanding of this impressive historical site in China. Jeffs’ and Kenderdine’s articles explain how three-dimensional models can be used as more than mere toys in digital art history, but as meaningful methods for thoughtful user engagement and scholarly, object-based analysis.

In the workshop portion of our class this week, I learned how to make a digital, three-dimensional model using the platforms AgiSoft and SketchFab. These platforms are accessible tools to create digital, three-dimensional models. Users do need to purchase an AgiSoft subscription, though. Jeffs also identified Sketchfab as a helpful platform for sharing and storing three-dimensional models. The creation of a good three-dimensional model depends largely on the quality of photographs taken of the object for digitization. In class, we used example images of a public sculpture found outside of Person Hall on UNC – Chapel Hill’s campus. This subject was ideal for photographing and reproducing digitally due to its lack of excessive texture, its relatively matte surface, and its even source of lighting. These variables will be important to consider for my own experiment in photogrammetry.

Three-dimensional modeling is a useful method for presenting an object digitally in a collection so that it may be given a greater sense of how it occupies space. In both the David Bowie article and the Smithsonian spacesuit, the viewer can grasp how the objects take up space. With the Smithsonian collection, the user can also view how light and shadow affect the object and its colors. Three-dimensional modeling presents a new opportunity in digital art history to expand to a different form of object digitization that will support analysis and access to objects in a collection.

Networks as a tool of decentering

November 7, 2026

This week, we discussed networks and webs as visualization tools. In articles like “Iterative Pasts and Linked Futures: A Feminist Approach to Modeling Data in Archives and Collections of Artists’ Publishing,” and “Perceptual Effects of Hierarchy in Art Historical Social Networks,” we heard from different digital art historians who engage with networks as a means of changing how we think about different artists and art movements. Multiple of these authors mention the idea that networks can be a method of disrupting or decentering hierarchy in data visualization. Opposed to the family tree, or even the timeline, no one point in a network can be treated as an origin point. This visual change does fundamentally alter the way we understand information, understanding each point relationally and on equal standing with one another.

Network visualization of contemporary artists https://blog.artist-info.com/visualizing-art-networks/

In “Perceptual Effects of Hierarchy in Art Historical Social Networks,” the authors created studies to see which kinds of visualizations were more clearly understood by students. Interestingly, a number of shortcomings showed up for networks, one being that for many students they were less legible and harder to retain. This makes sense to me, because the whole point of network visualizations is to nuance data—and nuance rarely lends itself to things like simplicity and clarity. In this case, I think this means we should just use the right tools for the right information. When visually depicting a family, I really think that the old-fashioned family tree is the most effective way to present information. It communicates visually what those relationships are in an accurate way.

From “Perceptual Effects of Hierarchy in Art Historical Social Networks”

However, when it comes to a group of artists that worked at the same time as each other, a network would be a much better representation. I’ve often thought I should make a network for my own purposes working on contemporary art, charting who’s done talks or exhibitions with who. In class, we looked at networks that charted different visual artists. This had its issues, mainly that the scope was not well defined, placing disparate artists alongside each other, some having many points and others having very few (despite the fact that they were well-known in their artist community at the time). For example, artists like Georgia O’Keeffe had no connections, despite the fact that she was an extremely well connected artist through Alfred Stieglitz’s studio 291 and then through her own reputation.

Like many of the projects we’ve looked at in this class, most issues with networks come down to an ill-defined goal or scope. But for our digital project this week, our goal was defined and very, very important: chart the cast of Dancing With The Stars!

We made this project with Kumu and while most of my classmates collaborated on one document, I did not get the memo—thus, I created my own network of just Season 7 of DWTS. I did this by uploading a .csv file which I converted from a chart I found on Wikipedia. I realized that Wikipedia actually lets you download .csv files directly from their site. Nonetheless, once I uploaded the data, it needed a lot of cleaning up. Here, I actually found Kumu frustrating: it’s interface doesn’t work exactly like a spreadsheet, even though it presumably could. Instead, you have to manually type everything in, and it’s harder to move categories around and copy/paste. I feel like this was one of my less successful projects in this class, but oh well.

Temporal Spatial Visualizations (or, timelines)

November 7, 2026

For this class, we were tasked with looking at a number of different timelines. Some of these incorporated mapping as well, and some didn’t, and some were less traditional that others. One of the map-timelines we looked at was Mapping Austrofascism, which charts the events of a single day in 1933 Germany. From the outset, the idea of mapping on a timeline the events in a single day in Vienna which ultimately show the Nazi takeover of Germany is really interesting. I always like projects that address histories which have been told many times over in a new way. The “topography” took me through a more traditional map, and the “topology was more akin to a timeline.

Visit at: https://mapping-austrofascism.campusmedius.net/?info=short

Throughout this project, a decision was made that vintage maps would be used (understandably), but their appearance was sometimes confusing and muddled. Still, this was a really cool idea for a project. Another project about modernist woman artist Mina Loy used a whole plethora of different digital projects, many of which were timelines.

See the project here: https://mina-loy.com/

These timelines tracked many different facets of Loy’s life and the historical context which surrounded her. Looking through this project, what struck me is just how effective a timeline can be for storytelling. I know it feels obvious or even rudimentary, but timelines are still one of the most effective ways to visualize how events relate to one another temporally. Art historians tend to under-utilize timelines, maybe because we tend to do everything through written essays. I have found in my short time teaching an introductory seminar to art history that we perhaps should bring back the timeline. If I find it hard to keep the order of all these written dates in my head, then I am sure that some of the undergraduates do too.

I was then inspired to look at some potential teaching tools related to timelines, and one that came up was from SmartHistory (which I often direct my students to). Though their timeline linked to very detailed information, it was more text-centered than a true visualization should be. Just scouring the internet, I found a timeline but it’s too broad to show to my students. Perhaps one day I’ll find a good one to share with my students, ideally before they have to take their final exam for the semester.

An art history timeline made by a Reddit user

However, what I found continuously is that a timeline can become very uninteresting and unengaging if you’re not invested in the subject matter, because in some cases there’s less interactivity than other kinds of digital projects have. This is where combining a timeline with a map can add interest and extra context which creates more investment from users. For my project this week, I decided to create a timeline from my own research interests: one that combined the history of surveillance with the history of art that addresses surveillance.

I have to say, I am really happy with how this turned out. To me, it makes a difference when these technologies and systems arose, but it tells us about the political context and motivations behind them. I was surprised at just how impactful it was for me to see the combined timeline between art and technology, which contextualized the art in a new way. I would like to keep expanding this timeline, potentially to use it in a project down the road.

Graphic Design is My Passion: The Art of Making Embodied, Effective Infographics

November 7, 2026

In On Rational, Scientific, Objective Viewpoints from Mythical, Imaginary, Impossible Standpoints, authors Catherine Ignazio and Lauren Klein advocate for an approach to infographics that allows viewers to feel alongside the graphic. This approach is certainly counter to so many scientific journals and political science groups which attempt to convey information through the most “objective” graphics possible. In the midst of the 2026 midterm elections, we were all being constantly inundated with these kinds of charts, graphs, and maps, all of which attempt to represent the election as accurately as possible, and many of which can be hard to read nonetheless.

Midterm election graphic from Al Jazeera which shows different types of potential map styles to represent election results

The day after the election, many different news outlets released a litany of various graphics or visualization tools—here’s one from Reuters that I found particularly interesting, because it used almost every chart format one could think of. When we think of ideal charts to show electoral college votes or state elections, we think of perhaps the least embodied and least subjective format possible: after all, isn’t the goal to communicate facts in a bipartisan way? If I were to make a chart that embodied my experience of this election, it’s aesthetics would certainly communicate joy, enthusiasm, etc… but these graphics are meant to communicate to diverse audiences.

However, as first argued by Donna Haraway in her Situated Knowledges , we should always treat claims to complete objectivity with some suspicion. To claim objectivity is to claim that there is no particular narrative or perspective being communicated, no act of persuading, and that is almost never the case when it comes to graphic design. As Ignazio and Klein put it: “Any communicating object that reflects choices about the selection and representation of reality is a rhetorical object.”1 The authors posit that, if this is true, we should be more mindful about what we’re actually trying to portray in graphics and charts. If we don’t limit ourselves to objectivity and indifference, a world of creative possibilities opens up, where emotion and embodied experiences could be communicated through data visualization.

Do Women Have to be Naked to Get Into the Met Museum? Guerilla Girls, 1989

Instead of “data visualization,” Klein and Ignazio point to “data visceralization.” This is where data and graphics teams work to visceralize the data they represent whether through the creation of multi-sensory interfaces, or making graphics that are meant to garner emotion in it’s audiences. Here there’s clearly an overlap with visual art more broadly. The Guerilla Girls made feminist infographics about inequity in the art world, but they did so in a format that was punchy and meant to garner affect. As the authors note, civil rights movements are well aware of the power of a good infographic.

Another example they gave was this chart which depicts gun deaths in the U.S. as years of life lost. Part of what makes it so effective is the animation, where you see the trajectory of one person (one dot) begin its arc before abruptly cutting off. See here: https://guns.periscopic.com/

In this case, movement is what pushed this graphic into the realm of the embodied and affective, but there are many different ways to do that. For my attempt at “data visceralization,” I wanted to see if I could think about politics in a new way. In class, we learned how to generate word clouds, and I uploaded the full texts of George W. Bush’s State of The Union addresses from his time in office. I don’t often see word clouds in political graphics, but I think that the words politicians say can tell us a lot about the mood of politics any given year, and it’s a bit more descriptive than, say, a map that shows approval ratings or votes. What I came up with was only semi-effective as a graphic, and I’d like to revisit the project. Many of the words were too small to read, and I wish I could make a version where you can click on each word and zoom in, and the graphic would tell you how many times that word was said. Even so, I think my choice of the flag shape and the colors of red white and blue did elevate the graphic.

Honestly, a good look at this told me a lot about what the republican president was offering to the public at this time and which narratives he was trying to draw out. I think the fact that “will” is by far the largest word says a lot. There were a lot of promises to be made and a lot of explanations too.

  1. https://data-feminism.mitpress.mit.edu/pub/5evfe9yd/release/5?from=10517&to=10638 ↩︎
« Older posts