In his article “Digital Art History as the Social History of Art: Towards the Disciplinary Relevance of Digital Methods,” Paul B. Jaskot outlines the ways in which he believes digital methodologies could alter how art historians frame their questions and offers some examples of what new frameworks could result from the usage of digital tools. Jaskot doesn’t just ask the question, “How can we use digital art history methods to support current research methods?” but goes further to ask, “How can digital art history as a methodology change the nature of the field?” He begins his article by placing digital art history in the context of critical art history by first addressing that in order for digital art history (and digital humanities in general) to thrive, it cannot be ignored that digital tools have often been the product of profit-seeking corporations. If we are to look at digital art history as a new methodology, we must acknowledge that we are beginning with a set of tools and frameworks that have roots in white, male, wealthy, Euro-centric perspectives. Jaskot uses this as a transition to his main argument that digital art history methods are uniquely positioned to analyze a much larger swath of society beyond dominant narratives, allowing bulk data to tell a story rather than granular interpretation of objects. A particularly salient point made is the vital difference between “digitized” and “digital” art history; Jaskot points to Johanna Drucker’s essay “Is There a ‘Digital’ Art History?” as the origin of this line of thinking, but ultimately finds that Drucker is still viewing digital art history as an extension of traditional art history frameworks and methodologies. To Jaskot, this is still a digitized point of view rather than a digital one, and in response he calls for a more nuanced analysis of the interplay of art historians’ tools, methods, and topics that ideally moves away from single-object focused meaning-making and into a wider analysis. Ultimately, Jaskot is advocating for using the disruption caused in the field by digital tools as an occasion for a more critical re-examination of current art historical research, allowing new questions and connections to be developed in conjunction with new high-capacity digital research methods.

In his current research, Jaskot uses the method of visualization to more critically examine cultural forces at work in his area of study. The project he discusses in this article that supports this use of wider frameworks for meaning-making was one that he published with Ivo Van Der Graaff, titled, “Historical Journals as Digital Sources: Mapping Architecture in Germany, 1914–24.” Jaskot uses some of the final resulting maps generated from this project in his article on digital art history to touch on one instance in which large-scale analysis can be more successful at illustrating relationships and their interplay with overarching social structures. His work is uniquely posed to explore wide-scale geographic visualizations; as a scholar of German architecture in the early to mid 20th century, he often focuses on Nazi Germany and the ways in which construction was used to enact violence. This topic is so embroiled in place and imperialist expansion,and benefits from the opportunity to impart scale visually. In his mapping project, he and his co-author Van Der Graaff had the goal of analyzing whether the process of construction itself was meaningful in the larger social and cultural landscape of Germany at this time. They describe the role of social art history in this process as “[…] not to explain a few monuments but—through a focus on what was built, where, and when—to increase our knowledge about the very social structures in which architects and buildings dynamically participate.” Van Der Graaff and Jaskot’s usage of tools in this case also provides an excellent example of the fundamental shifts in question-asking and meaning-making that Jaskot refers to in his article; rather than interpreting a topic through the lens of “great men” or overarching movements, they were able to look at construction as an expression of systemic changes.

I found this article to be an illuminating introduction to digital art history as a practice; it gives a clear idea of what makes digital humanities research different from current mindsets around sociocultural research. One of the reasons I chose to delve into Jaskot’s research a little further was because it truly is a compelling use case for digital art history methods that addresses how we can best utilize the absolute dearth of information that exists in repositories worldwide. The idea of “bulk” associated with digital records can often be framed as a challenge for archivists, and as a special collections worker who has studied archival theory, it was honestly slightly refreshing to see a researcher take that idea and put a more positive spin on it. Every record is a potentiality; having many records to comb through for relevant information forces creativity in their navigation. He also touches on some foundational appraisal theory with the line, “[…] more data does not equal more truth.” This resonated with me, and clarified Jaskot’s point that research (and especially digital methods of conveying research) is not necessarily a definitive statement, but an illustration of a specific web of relationships. The goal of creating a GIS map system such as this is not to lay bare the political and cultural landscape of Nazi Germany, but to illustrate patterns that may indicate connections between historical context and architectural form. This push and pull between retaining the characteristics of individual objects while at the same time examining their context in a wider system is certainly a tension more easily explored through digital tools that have fewer restraints on form. However, I would be curious to hear more about Jaskot’s opinion on how spatial analysis and social network analysis have facilitated the most “productive questions” of the four methodological areas he lists. “Digital storytelling” is a very wide and somewhat general description of a methodology with what seems like the capability to encourage more laypeople to engage with critical art history thought, and I would be interested in hearing about why exactly Jaskot has chosen not to examine this methodology further. Although, I will grant that since he is an architectural historian, spatial analysis is a far more natural expression of his research.

Works Referenced

Jaskot, Paul B. “Digital Art History as the Social History of Art: Towards the Disciplinary Relevance of Digital Methods.” Visual Resources 35, nos. 1–2 (2019): 21–33. https://doi.org/10.1080/01973762.2019.1553651.

Jaskot, Paul B., and Ivo Van Der Graaff. “Historical Journals as Digital Sources: Mapping Architecture in Germany, 1914–24.” Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 76, no. 4 (2017): 483–505.