This is the probably unit of the class I was the most excited about! I am very familiar with 3D modeling on the arts production side, but I had never had the chance to approach it from an art historical or pedagogical perspective. In particular, I was not familiar with embodiment theory; I was operating on a much more vibes-based understanding of what makes art immersive that’s informed by my own trial and error in creating immersive environments. Sarah Kenderdine’s article “Embodiment, Entanglement, and Immersion in Digital Cultural Heritage” explores some of what it means in a more philosophical sense to build a multisensory, non-static, kinesthetic representation of works of art. Part of Kenderdine’s argument is that these types of environments allow for a higher level of learning and emotional connection for students who are able to use these tools.
I think this builds on some interesting conversations about surrogacy that we’ve touched on over the course of the class. Namely, is there a way to create a facsimile that comes close to replicating the experience of the original work? While I think virtual reality and 3D models are incredible technological marvels (I was, in fact, prepared to devote my life to making them before realizing the work available to me was car insurance commercials and unpaid indie films), I’m not sure that they’re the real, true answer to that question. However, that does not necessarily render them useless. A theme I’ve been thinking on throughout the class is the space Kenderdine describes as “the borderline of the indexically real and the phantasmally virtual – between re‐embodiment and dis‐embodiment.” We all understand, on a fundamental level, that facsimiles are not real. I don’t think there is a way to capture the true aura of an original object, and yet, that has never once stopped anyone from trying to share their experience of that aura. Surrogates then end up existing in the space between truth and performance, never really able to lean into one side or the other. I don’t think we can start to have effective 3D and immersive surrogates unless we start explicitly breaking that kayfabe and being intentional about embracing the places where these methods fall short of reality.
If the ultimate goal of making an immersive environment or 3D digital representation of an object is to offer the opportunity to advance scholarship and investment in specific works or sites, as antithetical as it sounds, I don’t think you can neglect spectacle. Something my former professor Stuart Robertson said once really stuck with me, and even if it’s not necessarily a 1:1 analogy in this case, stick with me. In Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight, it was decided that they’d be flipping an 18-wheeler on set rather than rendering it in post production, where it would have been cheaper, safer, and still gotten the point across. But, you can bet that every person who was on set that day they flipped the truck walked away telling that story for years afterwards. Sometimes, you just have to do things because they’re cool! And while that is an interesting moment in cinema history, it certainly didn’t detract from the story that was being told; if you bring up The Dark Knight to someone, they’re much more likely to acknowledge the performances in the film than the truck flip. To that end, wonder and awe can have a place in pedagogy, and that doesn’t necessarily mean that the substantive intellectual content you’re leading them to is cheapened. If the gimmick truly supports the narrative you are trying to tell and gets more people to engage with something they may not have before, it is worth doing.
It was exciting for me to get back into photogrammetry during this week! One of my mentors at SCAD wrote his thesis on incorporating photogrammetry into visual effects curriculums, and a few of my classmates and I got to help start up a photogrammetry club at the school. While the technology has been around for a while, as a 21 year old in 2018 it seemed like it was magic! I was also fortunate enough to be in lovely Savannah as I was learning, which has some incredible architecture that was relatively easy to capture. Although I never finished this project, here’s a screenshot of a model I created depicting a set of stairs down to River Street that my friends and I called “The Bachelorette Killer.”

And here’s a turnaround of an unpatched model of my friend’s plushie that I included in my demo reel.

We got to generate the beginnings of a model in our workshop, and I’ll admit I was surprised how well it worked with only 12 images! Typically, we recommended 30-80 photos in our workshops, but that many high-resolution photos would have made this short workshop take much, much longer.

I’d also like to point out something that you may not know if you haven’t ever 3D modeled before. Take a look at the wireframe for the model, and take a look at how many faces it has.

For any kind of practical purpose, this is not best practice. In order to make models created with photogrammetry usable in production without ballooning your render time (or slowing down your real-time viewer), you’d need to decimate and retopologize this model. Without getting too much into the weeds of 3D modeling workflows, this means that you redraw the faces in a more logical way that does not remove detail from the model itself. Here’s an image that shows what exactly retopologizing looks like- notice how the detail of the form is not being lost, but the wireframe looks like something you can understand.

For our purposes in this class, retopologizing is not a pressing issue- I only bring it up because if you want to create a model that you want people to actually use, reuse, and distribute, you will need to take steps to prevent it from lagging people’s computers and browsers.
Kenderdine, Sarah. “Embodiment, Entanglement, and Immersion in Digital Cultural Heritage.” In A New Companion to Digital Humanities, 1st ed., edited by Susan Schreibman, Ray Siemens, and John Unsworth. Wiley, 2015. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118680605.ch2.



















