Beyond the Women's Building

Women Architects and World Fairs

Page 6 of 8

Scanning Images and Digital Surrogates

pixelated image of a skeleton being hugged by an armored figure.
[Scanned image from Vermis I]. plastiboo, Vermis I: Lost Dungeons and Forbidden Woods, 11th printing, 2026. Used here for educational and commentary purposes; no copyright infringement intended. All rights remain with the original owner.

Scanning this image from Vermis I: Lost Dungeons and Forbidden Woods by plastiboo1 made me consider the layers of processing necessary to make a reproduction similar to the original. To get this image to come close to the original image in Vermis, I had to not only use a high-resolution scanner with the matching software, but to distort the original itself. I had to hold the book at an awkward angle, pressing it against the glass of the scanner enough to grab the image clearly without causing the spine to crack or the pages to be damaged (While this was with my personal copy of Vermis and I do not mind a cracked spine and other signs of wear, I wanted to practice as if it were not my own book). Using a paperback copy likely helped this process but I still would have had to take additional time if I had wanted the complete page, as parts of the full page were cut off or too shadowed. Even with the portion clearly scanned, I had to add a sepia photo filter to achieve the closest possible reproduction of the original in the time allotted as the scanner had dramatically brightened the image. I also had to add a Gaussian blur in Photoshop to smooth the honeycomb texture the scanner adds to books.

Emma Stanford in “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates” explains the long lineage of reproductions, photographs, and other surrogates used in the study of art history.2 Perhaps more importantly, Stanford argues that these surrogates often go unnoticed. They are such a necessary part of our study and pedagogical process that we no longer think of them as imperfect substitutions. If we do notice, we often do not think of just how distant our surrogates remain from the original artwork.

How far removed is my scan from the original image? Removing it from the book takes it out of context. It is also removed from the surrounding page graphics and faux signs of use that were cropped out. While that doesn’t make it useless for study, its use is not the same as the original image.

I can zoom in on the scanned image.
Close up of the skeletons's skull from the previous image
Close up of the skeleton’s skull. Notably the honeycomb artifacting from the scanner is still visible in extreme close up. [Close up of scanned image from Vermis I]. plastiboo, Vermis I: Lost Dungeons and Forbidden Woods, 11th printing, 2026. Used here for educational and commentary purposes; no copyright infringement intended. All rights remain with the original owner.
I can view it directly beside a comparison image.
pixelated image of a skeleton being hugged by an armored figure.
[Scanned image from Vermis I]. plastiboo, Vermis I: Lost Dungeons and Forbidden Woods, 11th printing, 2026. Used here for educational and commentary purposes; no copyright infringement intended. All rights remain with the original owner.
Screenshot of Wizardry I showing the maze on dungeon level 1
Screenshot of Wizardry: Proving Grounds of the Mad Overlord for the IBM PC (MS-DOS), level 1 of the maze. Orion Blastar, Wikimedia Commons, 2013. Licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

But what happens when the reproduction is all that remains of a work or the only accessible version?

I have mixed feelings on video game emulators. I acknowledge that they are invaluable for making video games accessible and have amazing archival potential. Despite legal challenges, emulators may be the only cost-effective, practical way to preserve some games. Still, what is lost when we consider a video game as software alone? Hardware is an important part of video-game art, whether the game is played on a console or a computer. Compatible hardware may no longer exist for the original physical game, making emulation a practical means of preserving access. Yet an emulator is still a surrogate, not a complete replacement for the original. Treating the code or software as the game itself can overlook the role of hardware in shaping the experience.

When an exhibit uses the same generic controller and display for all the games presented, what changes? Are the awkward shape and biting corners of an NES controller part of an NES game? I don’t believe there is a blanket answer to every exhibit, game, or situation. Without asking the question, we don’t explore other options.

How deep should the layers of surrogacy go? If original hardware could not be sourced, STL files for 3D models of consoles and controllers could probably be found. Is a printed hardware replica helpful surrogate or deception? Nintendo attracted considerable criticism after visitors discovered that its official museum relied on PC emulation.3 Nintendo has a long history of holding their copyright with an iron fist, pursuing legal action against mods and emulators. But when faced with presenting its own history, Nintendo also had to rely on the same surrogates used by game researchers to access their back catalog. Instead of facing this paradox, they attempted to hide it, using system controllers fed into a wall with the screen embedded above.

Even when the layers of surrogacy are not deliberately hidden, thinking of emulation in the same space as a slide projector in an art class calls into question what is included and what is excluded from the experience. The Internet Archive hosts playable MS-DOS games in it’s Software Library (Sorry not sorry for ruining any plans you had this evening if you didn’t know about this resource already).4 When you click play on a game, after a brief modern download screen for the emulator, a super-speed version of the DOS process of opening a DOS game flashes by. Are there circumstances where you should still have to type in the path in the blinking white text of the black DOS box while you frantically try to find the scrap of paper you wrote your save extension on? Should this process be part of the emulation? Should original load times or run times be emulated? Would doing so bring something valuable to the experience of video games as art? Would this surrogacy of nuance of experience be valuable or deceptive since modern technology does not require these processes?


  1. Plastiboo, Vermis I : Lost Dungeons and Forbidden Woods : Official Guide, ed. Michele Nitri, with Marco Cirillo Pedri, Vermis 1 (2023; 11th printing, Hollow Press, 2026), Paperback (Regular Edition).↩︎

  2. Emma Stanford, “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates,” in The Routledge Companion to Digital Humanities and Art History, 1st ed., ed. Kathryn Brown (Routledge, 2020), https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429505188-19.↩︎

  3. Andy Edser, “The Official Nintendo Museum Appears to Be Emulating SNES Games on a Windows PC, Which Is Slightly Embarrassing,” Hardware, PC Gamer, October 14, 2024, https://www.pcgamer.com/hardware/the-official-nintendo-museum-appears-to-be-emulating-snes-games-on-a-windows-pc-which-is-slightly-embarrassing/.↩︎

  4. Internet Archive, “Software Library: MS-DOS Games,” Software Library: MS-DOS Games, accessed August 31, 2026, https://archive.org/details/softwarelibrary_msdos_games.↩︎

On digital surrogacy of magazines.

People vol. 36, no. 7.

During my lifetime, magazines went from a waiting room stable, an airplane must-have, and a beloved piece of mail in my mailbox to nearly entirely obsolete. Culturally, not much is different. People are still interested in reading the news, tabloids or other specialized publications. What has changed is the habit of how they get this information. The format in which they read has evolved to the digital. Why would someone pay for a magazine when they could read the exact same article on the internet for free? Undeniably, users prefer convenience above all else when engaging with media. This trend exists outside of magazines. Video streaming replaced DVD, music streaming replaced CD, and even online shopping has replaced the need to shop in person. The user is given convenience of time, of access, of space, of cost, and of selection. “You can just do it online” has become a defining statement of our current era of user experience. Yet, are these experiences the same? The product may be the same – for magazines, this means getting the same information – but digital surrogates do not fully emulate the embodied experience of physical engagement. Furthermore, when something is unavailable digitally, suddenly the convenience evaporates. Emma Stanford evaluates the user experience with digital surrogates in her chapter “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates.” Where digitization is a great way to enable multi-platform conveniences, it also necessitates altering the source material. Digital surrogacy is a fundamentally different user experience, and magazines are a model of these differences.

“The hallmark of a bad digital surrogate is that its badness cannot be gauged, because important contextual details are missing. Put another way, there are no bad digital surrogates—only misleading and poorly described ones.”
A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates p210. Emma Stanford.

Emma Stanford argues that digital surrogates are neither perfect substitutes nor are they threats to originals. To tie back to my own previous blog post, digital surrogates do not replace the experience of engaging with works in person. They are not inherently bad nor inherently good. Digitized works exist in their own category as approximations. Their value is in their ability to reproduce and disseminate works, but in turn, they freeze a work into one specific viewing model. This is where digital archivists have to be the most mindful. They want to be sure that they are using best practices and good equipment when digitizing works. Digital archivists have to use very specialized equipment and the work can be quite time consuming. This step is critical and is the invisible labor behind all digital surrogates. What is chosen for digitization depends heavily on the resources and interest of the archivists. That which is given the most attention is most likely to be digitized (and digitized well). There are all kinds of works that are not digitized, and to illustrate the difference between the physical and the digital, I want to make an example out of a personal collection of mine.

I am deeply interested in keeping up with celebrity news. One of my favorite sources for this information is the magazine People. Physical issues have been available since 1974, and now the magazine can be accessed through their website and on social media platforms. Articles and issues published after about 2008 are fairly easy to access through their in-site navigation. The website even offers some web-exclusive articles such as the People StyleWatch section. The online platform also allows for functionality that would otherwise be unavailable in the print format. To name a few, users can click links to products and go directly to its shopping page, they can leave comments on articles, and they can search through tags to read more on news that interests them. All of these conveniences have made it so the digital format has surpassed the physical in popularity. Yet, on the other side, the physical issue has noticeable differences.

Below are two photo scans from the cover article of People vol. 36, no. 7, Patrick Swayze’s Sexiest Man Alive issue from August 26 1991 (rotated for readability). These are digitizations I made using my personal physical copy of the issue.

Digitized spread from Park, Jeannie. “Body and Soul.” People, August 26, 1991.


And below is a screenshot of the digital surrogate of the same article.

Capture from Wayback Machine archive of “Body and Soul.” https://web.archive.org/web/20241115043810/https://people.com/archive/cover-story-body-and-soul-vol-36-no-7/.

The differences should be immediately apparent. In the printed article, the text is formatted around the photos, there are bold letters and block quotes, and the issue was printed in a rotated vertical format. The emphasis in the web version is on the content of the text, and even still, it does not include all of the text. This web digital surrogate – to use Stanford’s reasoning – is bad. It lacks a great deal of contextual information that the print version had. Yet, this is the only version available online as there are – in my search – no photo scans of the issue online. Complicatedly, I was only able to find the digital article on the Wayback Machine – itself a digital surrogate of the internet and not an exact approximation of viewing the article at the time it was published online. It seems the article has been archived from the site and is inaccessible using the site’s navigation bar. Stanford points out that even when works are made digitally accessible, they may not stay accessible forever thereby making the digitization efforts disappear.

So, with all these problems, what is the point of digitization of older magazines at all?

“…while digital surrogates may not be perfect, they are better than nothing, and the need for them is urgent.”
A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates p208. Emma Stanford.

In my perspective, reading this specific issue in person was the only complete option. Even my digitization is itself a digital surrogate, and I used it in this post to serve as a stand in for the actual object. By rotating the pages, I modified the images in a way that alters your viewing experience. The magazine is also more than just the one article. I found the other articles, the vintage advertisements, and the tactile experiences all shaped how I engaged with this piece of media. I love collecting physical media, but of course this is not always an option for everyone. And while the demand for this issue might not be high, I think it would be a good idea for me to photo scan the rest of the pages and upload them. Now, if only I could figure out if that is legal under copyright… that is a thought for another day.

Digitization: The Future of Museum Collections

           

I decided to digitize a photograph of my dog, Jax, this past week in Digital Art History. In this educational exercise, I practiced how to properly scan, digitally adjust colors, and write alt text for this digital reproduction of Jax’s photograph. This experience gave me insight—albeit on a micro-scale—of the digitization protocols of museums, libraries, and cultural institutions.

Digitization is a crucial step forward for museums, libraries, and cultural institutions to broaden access to their collections. In the book chapter “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates: Evaluating and Contextualizing a Rapidly Changing Resource” Emma Standford explains the history, best practices, challenges, and potential of digitization for museums and cultural institutions. Digitizing collections creates the potential for broader access to art, documents, and objects.

Digitization is inherently a surrogate for the original, whether it’s a digital copy of a painting or a digitized photograph of a living, breathing golden retriever. Surrogates are not new to the field of art history. As early as 1890, Herman Grim integrated a lantern slide projector into his lectures, using projected images as surrogates for works of art and architecture.[1] Digitization and digital photography allowed the transition from physical slides to digital projected images in the art history classroom. Even more advanced technology and software development allow for interactive methods of viewing objects or architectural spaces. It is impossible to digitally re-create the experience of viewing an object in-person, but the versatility of digital surrogates also grants viewers access to different methods of interaction with an object.

Digital-storytelling is a popular way to interact with the digital surrogate of an object. It primarily serves an educational purpose. In class we viewed an example of the collaborative software of the International Image Interoperability Framework (IIF), the Victoria and Albert Museum’s Compariscope that allows viewers to overlay The Night Watch by Rembrandt van Rijn over the artist’s original sketches. This tool encourages users to study the artist’s process and transition from a first sketch to the final painting. In a previous art history course, I also played with the publicly sponsored “interactive documentary” Jheronimus Bosch, the Garden of Earthly Delights, which creates an audio-visual experience for the user. [2] It pairs music with specific scenes in Bosch’s triptych, offers explanations for details in the painting, and allows the viewer to closely examine the work. These digital resources are not analytical in nature, but, as digital-storytelling tools, they do help share scholarly research in the classroom and the museum.

            Besides its educational advantages, digitization ultimately improves and broadens access to an institution’s collections. As a student with experience working in archives and special collections libraries, I have participated in digitization projects and witnessed their utility. For example, I scanned large, old, and fragile land survey maps for the Newport Historical Society while working in the Salve Regina University Archives. This project presented a few nuances to digitization that Stanford also elaborates upon in her chapter.

First, the necessity to update and improve the image quality of the digitized maps indicated institutions’ ongoing struggle to keep up with the most current technology. Stanford noted that even since the advent of digital photography, there are clear improvements in image quality from an object digitized twenty years ago and five years ago. [3] I learned that the Newport Historical Society had also already digitized the maps, but the University recently acquired a scanner that could capture significantly more depth per square inch. The Newport Historical Society’s decision to re-scan the maps demonstrated the necessity to maintain and update digital collections as technology improves.

Another factor influencing an institution’s digitization practices is access to the proper technology. In the case of the Newport Historical Society maps, it involved reaching out and collaborating with another institution, the Salve Regina University Archives. This may be an optimal solution for smaller, local institutions, but the wealth and resources available to an institution affects the quantity, quality, and type of objects in a collection that get digitized.

Stanford argues that determining what and how objects or documents are digitized is inherently subjective.[4] Although large institutions may have the financial autonomy to run their own digitization experiments, most non-profit institutions rely on private or corporate donors or grants. This ultimately affects what museums choose to digitize because access to essential funding may be at stake.

            Hans Haacke outlines the precarious position of museums between independence and accountability to donors in the chapter “Museums: Managers of Consciousness” in the book Grasping the World: The Idea of the Museum.[5] Haacke explains that museums are inevitably political institutions since they are accountable to those—either through public, government grants or private, corporate sponsorships—that control funding.[6] This makes the operational decisions of museums, like choosing what and how to digitize a collection, dependent on the source of funding for the project. In the case of corporate sponsorships, Haacke considers, museums may face even greater pressure to produce impressive, “box office” exhibitions.[7] This similar self-censorship is also true for digitization projects. Digitization projects, like exhibitions, are stuck between aiming to provide greater access to their collections while also molding projects to fit within a grant’s parameters or to appease a private donor or corporate sponsor.

            Despite digitization’s inherent subjectivity, responsiveness to new technology, and dependence on adequate funding and resources, it is clearly a significant benefit for museums, libraries, and cultural institutions that grew from the rapid technological advancement of the last twenty years. Digitization increases access to art, objects, and documents (and photographs to pets!) while also facilitating the creation of digital humanities projects. The challenges to digitization are great, but the potential for broadened access to collections for research, education, and even just general interest is worth the effort.


[1] Alison Langmead, “Art and Architectural History and the Performative, Mindful Practice of the Digital Humanities,” Journal of Interactive Technology and Pedagogy, no. 12 (February 2018), 2.

[2] Pieter van Huystee Film, NTR, Jheronimus Bosch, the Garden of Earthly Delights (Pieter van Huystee Film, NTR, 2016), https://archief.ntr.nl/tuinderlusten/en.html#.

[3] Emma Standford, “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates: Contextualizing a Rapidly Changing Resource,” in The Routledge Companion to Digital Humanities and Art History, ed. by Kathryn Brown (Routledge, 2020), 206.

[4] Standford, “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates,” 205.

[5] Hans Haacke, “Museums: Managers of Consciousness,” in Grasping the World: The Idea of the Museum, eds. Donald Preziosi and Claire Farago (Routledge, 2020), 400-412.

[6] Haacke, “Museums: Managers of Consciousness,” 407-408.

[7] Haacke, “Museums: Managers of Consciousness,” 409.

Thinking Beyond the Digital and Material Divide

As a textile historian, my research often places me in the room with the objects I study. The tactile experience of seeing and handling the art teaches me not only how a cloth was made, but why its artist(s) chose to create it with a particular material or design. So when I approached this week’s readings, all about the digitization of art, images, and text descriptions, it is fair to say I felt out of my element. It’s one thing to analyze the art object through the screen, another to analyze the affect of the screen itself! But reflecting on my practice with digitization tools and how they pushed me to think beyond the material aspects of experiencing art, I’m inspired to understand the visualization of textiles using both a physical and digital space.

In “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates: Evaluating and Contextualizing a Rapidly Changing Resource,” author Emma Stanford makes the case that the reproduction of art through images needs to be investigated for both its benefits and limitations to object interpretation in the digital age. She sees the danger of digital images to be their limitless reach and reproduction, and proposes historians combat this by writing metadata for images and having said data by accessible to the public. In her words, this solution tackles the root of the problem with the “digital surrogacy” of online images, which is that, “there are no bad digital surrogates— only misleading and poorly described ones (Stanford 2020, 2010).” This sentiment came up in another context this week, as I was preparing for my lesson plan on the history of photography, in which my class and I were discussing how we interpret photographs versus paintings. Similar to the opening of Stanford’s essay, the focus of our class was on the innovations of William Henry Fox Talbot’s calotype and his subsequent book The Pencil of Nature. To illustrate the pervasiveness of facsimiles today, which Talbot himself predicted, I had the students scroll through their social media and consider what images they saw, for what reasons, and the quantity of images that appeared on their screen. As we discussed the exercise, an observation was made that many images posted by influencers, companies, and even real-life friends were composed to look candid, when they were actually staged for the photo, and then curated to share. In other words, their presentation does not tell a full story. Interpreting Stanford’s concern for digital facsimiles with this conversation prompted me to think about the contemporary state of digital collections, where the viewing experience with an object is up to the quality and number of photos uploaded to a database.

What is included, omitted, or particular to digital collections, edited from the final photo will not invoke the same looking experience one would have seeing the physical object up-close. I can attest to this fact, as there have been many textiles I needed to see up-close before determining their aesthetic and/or material qualities. Take for example, this gara cloth (a wax-resist textile made in Sierra Leone) that I had the opportunity to see in-person at the North Carolina Museum of Art. Before viewing the work, I did not have many thoughts on it, beyond that it used a resist-dye technique I wanted to see for a research project.


On the left: Photo of gara cloth taken in the North Carolina Museum of Art’s collection by me, June 26, 2026.

On the right: “Wax-stamped resist-dyed Textile (gara),” early 1970s. Synthetic, indigo, and kola nut dyes with various resist techniques, on damask cotton cloth. North Carolina Museum of Art, 2020.9.3. Photograph taken from their collections website.

But upon seeing this textile in person I was drawn into its beauty. Until I viewed it in-person, I didn’t realize the damask (satin-weave) cotton which backgrounds the indigo pattern has a gridded, reflective surface. This one layer added a dimensionality to the cloth I would have never seen in the digital image. Even this image doesn’t do it justice! Moving around the room I was in, I realized it was this experience, moving with and looking closely at the textile in the light, which was integral to understanding its value as clothing. It is one thing to say that it has a gridded pattern which switches between horizontal stripes and flowers, and another to say that its satin sheen backing would have complimented the dyed pattern, flattering the wearer’s body and valuing this textile as a quality cloth. While the first description is not deceitful, or entirely inaccurate, it does not draw the viewer into the full experience of looking at and wearing a textile such as this one. So how do we reconcile our dependence on digital images with the absence of material objects?

Last week, when I was practicing with digitization tools for alt text and other ADA accessibility tools, I connected the interpretations of visual language they provide with the need for clarity and alternative modes of seeing with digital images. It is precisely because digital tools can’t stand in for material objects that they are an integral part of viewing art. Before this week, I thought of alt text was a tool used by and for visually impaired people only. But exploration of how it is written made me consider how visual language goes beyond just what you see in the moment. It also considers the details others can experience only through words. By reflecting on how we write about the art we observe, alt text is no longer a simple tool, but also an alternative method for collecting data. This data may help us put our own ways of seeing into a larger context.

Note: alt-text and digital images will be added to this post in a future update.

Digital Surrogacies and the Loss of Three-Dimensionality in Two-Dimensional Reproductions

30 August 2026

This week I have chosen to focus my blog post on Emma Stanford’s “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates: Evaluating and Contextualizing a Rapidly Changing Resource” (2020) because of my own interest in and past use of digital surrogates in art history. The article briefly highlights the history of digital surrogates—especially through photography—and the inequalities in the materials available digitally to the public. 

Especially noteworthy is Stanford’s note on the materials chosen for digitization being influenced by the person or group funding the digitization project, such as the digital collections of the Bodleian Libraries at the University of Oxford being in-proportionately slanted towards Hebrew manuscripts due to significant funding by the Polonsky Foundation from 2012 to 20171 . While this is not inherently an issue since libraries and museums are often tight on funding for digital projects, external funding does prioritize certain objects over others for digitization, potentially feeding into the historic cycle of certain areas of art and history being prioritized over others. In particular, objects associated with non-Western histories and cultures have historically received the short end of the stick in digitization, as there are fewer external foundations to privately-fund projects. This being said, is some digitization—even if it is not proportional to an institution’s overall collection—still worth accepting external funding for as opposed to no digitization?



I would like to turn the remainder of this blog post towards another topic discussed by author Emma Stanford: the the unique difficulties that arise when digitizing three-dimensional objects into a (mostly) two-dimensional digital format. Stanford alludes to this idea when she discusses the pitfalls of digital reproductions, writing “a two-dimensional digital surrogate of that object is frozen at a particular angle, under a particular light, and presented with a particular viewing experience in mind.”2. Since three-dimensional objects are intended to be viewed from multiple angles, capturing a two-dimensional snapshot of the object only digitizes a single viewing angle. Details—both significant and minute—are lost in two-dimensional reproductions of three-dimensional objects. 

Take Bernini’s The Rape of Proserpina (1621-1622) for example. Now housed at the Galleria Borghese in Rome, the sculpture stands 116 inches (295 cm) in height and is displayed towards the center of a room, allowing visitors to walk around it and view the sculpture from all sides. From first glance, Bernini’s sculpture is an emotional, intricate depiction of the mythological tale, showcasing a terrified Proserpina as she is abducted by the god Pluto and dragged to the Underworld. She famously cries out as she is caught, the essence of which was rendered in her facial features by Bernini. Any viewer of this sculpture in-person would likely take the time to circle the work, identifying the minute features carved by Bernini that give insights into the emotions of the individuals portrayed.

The Rape of Proserpina has been reproduced many times in a two-dimensional format in the centuries since its creation. Nicolas Dorigny (a French-born engraver) produced an engraving of the sculpture that was published in the volume “Domenico de and Paolo Alessandro Maffei. Raccolta di statue antiche e moderne” (1704) by Domenico di’Rossi3 as plate LXVIII. This image shows Bernini’s sculpture from a three-quarters angle, centralizing more on Pluto than Proserpina. Since travel was difficult in 1704 when the engraving was published, Dorigny’s reproduction may have been the only way for an individual in England to see the work.
 

What does a viewer lose when only seeing Bernini’s The Rape of Proserpina through Nicolas Dorigny’s engraving? For starters, only one vantage point of the sculpture is published in the 1704 volume, so readers would not have a reproduction of the back side of the figures. Any details that were carved outside of Dorigny’s reproduction vantage point would be virtually nonexistent to an individual looking at his engraving. While Dorigny’s engraving intentionally focuses on Pluto as the central figure in his reproduction—as evidenced by framing the engraving to have him as the

center of the image, not Proserpina—Bernini’s sculpture when viewed from the back shifts the attention to Proserpina. From the back, she is the central figure with the highest range of motion and emotion, not Pluto. Proserpina is physically higher than Pluto is due to her outstretched arm, drawing the viewer’s eye towards her. Moreover, the intricate movements in the fabric of her clothing highlight the surprise she felt as she was suddenly abducted by Pluto, as she is clothed from the back but nude from the front—suggesting she was caught in a state of surprise. 

In reproducing only one vantage point of Bernini’s The Rape of Proserpina, Nicholas Dorigny’s engraving cuts out parts of the story told by Bernini—whether intentionally or unintentionally. Viewers are forced to see the story from a single perspective, mimicking the physical viewing experience relegated to a single perspective as well. Modern photographs still do the same thing. Photographs of Bernini’s work continue to exclude certain aspects of the three-dimensional sculpture. Many images taken from the same vantage point as Dorigny’s engraving completely exclude the inclusion of Cerberus beneath Proserpina, an important contextualization for the work’s story. The pressure with which Pluto grips Proserpina is also often missing from two-dimensional reproductions of the sculpture, as indicated by the strong grip he holds on her upper left thigh. 

In the end, while two-dimensional reproductions are often the easier and more cost-effective method of digitizing works of three-dimensional art for wider distribution (and for many years were the only method of doing so), three-dimensional methods will always prevail over two-dimensional ones in accuracy. (Accuracy here being defined as a means of fully capturing all of the details of a work of art). Photogrammetric models of Bernini’s The Rape of Proserpina have been published online, allowing viewers to see the anguish on Proserpina’s face from a better angle, as she faces towards the ceiling in the ten-foot tall sculpture. 



For the second part of my blog post I was tasked with uploaded scans completed earlier this week in class. We completed a digitization workshop in which each student scanned an image and a body of text of their choice. Adjustments were then made to the digitized files as needed in Photoshop, including cropping and minor color adjustments (for the image) and a very-unsuccessful attempt at OCR for the (handwritten) text. Apparently my handwriting is not legible to Adobe Acrobat.

Digitized scan of a postcard I received from a friend while she was in Athens.


Below is a scan of my reading notes from my museum studies seminar this semester. They come from an article assigned for reading: Carol Duncan and Alan Wallach, “The Museum of Modern Art as Late Capitalist Ritual,” in Preziosi and Farago, eds., Grasping the World, Part V, chapter 1.

I wouldn’t recommend you download them, unless you have a particular interest in Marxism and museum studies.

  1. Emma Stanford, “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates: Evaluating and Contextualizing a Rapidly Changing Resource,” Routledge Companion, pp. 205.  ↩︎
  2. Stanford, pp.207. ↩︎
  3. Rossi, Domenico de’, “Raccolta di statue antiche e moderne: data in luce sotto i gloriosi auspici della Santita di N.S. Papa Clemente XI.” Stamperia della Pace. Rome. 1704. Available online via Internet Archive. ↩︎

Copies of copies of copies

This week’s readings and activities were right up my alley- ever since beginning my career transition to cultural heritage four years ago as a volunteer cataloging and digitizing local history, the question of whether or not surrogates are effective has been a pressing question to me. As someone who also has a hefty background in more technical image processing as a compositor, the bits and bytes we use to represent ourselves, our stories, and our society have certainly framed a lot of the ways that I approach cultural heritage. To create, in one form or another, is to abstract. But how many layers of abstraction and how many copies of copies can exist before they become something different altogether? It’s quite a philosophical topic, and Emma Stanford’s article “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates” did a fantastic job in laying out the points of interest in this discussion succinctly. 

Of course, no conversation about representation of an original is complete without at least acknowledging Walter Benjamin. The conversation of how accurate a surrogate could possibly be has its genesis in the advent of the publicly accessible camera; now that any person can capture an accurate image, what purpose does the original serve? Benjamin’s response (the concept of “aura”) points to the unique physicality of viewing originals, and nearly a hundred years later, we still unequivocally prefer to see the original, regardless of medium. Stanford, however, classifies this as a fundamental (if common) misunderstanding of what the purpose of a surrogate for an art object is. It is neither “a perfect substitute or […] a threat to the original’s authenticity”: It is a tool for delivering a singular perspective of a three-dimensional object, which comes with its own set of pros and cons. As we move beyond simple 2D recreations of objects and into the realm of more advanced digital surrogates (such as the parallax viewer tool created by the Victoria and Albert museum that we explored in class), these questions are pushed back to the forefront of the field. Whether or not more advanced surrogates will actually advance the study of art history seems to be the focus of exploration in this course.

Stanford also touches on something absolutely vital to the creation of advanced surrogates for long-term use: longevity. From an archival standpoint, we have been inundated since day one with the mantra “the archivist is not neutral,” and the same goes for collecting institutions of all kinds. What gets saved, acquired, processed, and made accessible is a slice of a slice of a slice of the overall experience of humanity. I’ve always appreciated Michelle Caswell’s quote, “Not all events ­are recorded; not all records ­are incorporated into archives; not all archives ­are used to tell stories; not all stories are used to write history. Power is implicated in each of these moments; which stories get told, which get for­got­ten, when, and by whom, is inextricably linked ­to the power to tell and to remain silent.” The introduction of power into the equation makes these choices of what and how to digitize that much more pressing and complex. When we take into account the resources necessary to maintain surrogates long-term, this problem further devolves into a case of the haves and have-nots. So, from step zero, there is a massive amount of push and pull from external sources that clouds our ability to answer the question of efficacy. Stafford also echoed a sentiment that anyone who has ever worked with digital objects of any kind has encountered; the tools are arbitrary, and it is the fundamental way of approaching a specific problem that ultimately determines how successful the result will be. 

In taking the time to explore what it takes to make a clean, high-quality, and accessible static digital image, we got to experience first-hand how some of these small decisions quickly shape the experience of the surrogate’s viewer. I brought in a book I purchased for an art history course nearly a decade ago titled The Downtown Book: The New York Art Scene 1974-1984 because I was kind of tickled by the idea of reproducing an image from an era focused on what it means to reproduce, re-contextualize, and re-appropriate an image. I scanned a page with one of Barbara Kruger’s untitled works from 1981 (Your gaze hits the side of my face) printed on it, and got to see firsthand what was lost in the interaction. For instance, when on exhibit, the work is placed in a frame painted bright red- her signature accent color for this era of her work. The frame’s vibrancy only partially made it into the image in the book, and when scanning the image in the book, the stark red border was only further diminished by my (somewhat rushed) cropping job. Frames are such a large part of presentation, and Stanford even describes them in the article as a context clue for the larger meaning of a work. Sure, it’s just a thin, red border, but red is such a prominent part of Kruger’s visual language and seeing it get smaller and smaller in this exercise made me a little sad! Some artifacting from the book’s printing was also included in the scan; there is an inherent graininess to the work, but this scan overly exaggerates its texture. I played around with frequency separation (a retouching method used often for skin in beauty photography) as a method of reducing texture, but ultimately found that separating the grain of the image from the grain of the book’s printing to be nearly impossible. 

Black-and-white photograph of the side profile of a classical marble female bust. Running vertically down the left edge are eight stacked black rectangles containing bold, white, capitalized text that reads: "YOUR GAZE HITS THE SIDE OF MY FACE."
Barbara Kruger
Untitled (Your gaze hits the side of my face), 1981
As scanned by me from The Downtown Book
Black-and-white photograph of the side profile of a classical marble female bust. Running vertically down the left edge are eight stacked black rectangles containing bold, white, capitalized text that reads: "YOUR GAZE HITS THE SIDE OF MY FACE."
Barbara Kruger
Untitled (Your gaze hits the side of my face), 1981
A more professional digitization of the piece.

I was, however, much more satisfied with the scans for two additional items that I brought in to compare how digitizing printed and original works differed. The postcard I brought, which was another printed material, had a similar result as far as added texture and graininess. In this case though, the artifacting present is much more in keeping with the nature of a cheaply printed souvenir photo postcard. I also know for a fact that many, many photos have been taken of this exact angle of downtown over the years (I’ve encountered many a Raleigh skyline postcard in my years with the City’s special collections), so the “aura” of the photo and of the original view feels less important in the digital reproduction from my perspective. I was also quite happy with how the scan of my linocut print (one of my very first) turned out. As a print, which is technically another type of “copy,” I feel like this surrogate comes pretty close to the original intent for the viewing of this work, and I felt a lot more confident being able to edit it myself to fit that view. I wonder if in today’s age, digital reproductions (from living artists, at least) are best obtained from the artist themselves? I think if artists were included in the determination of a “particular interpretation” of their work, as Stanford describes, it would be more accurate; the idea of digital surrogates suddenly becomes much more feasible for artists currently working.

A postcard-style photograph of the Raleigh, North Carolina skyline at twilight. In the upper left corner, white stylized text reads "Raleigh" over "North Carolina".
A souvenir postcard depicting the Raleigh, North Carolina skyline at dusk. Photo by Bill Cobb.
A black-and-white linocut print showing a UFO abducting a spotted cow at night.
4″x6″ Linocut print
Kat Cardullo, 2024

Benjamin, Walter. “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction.” In Illuminations, edited by Hannah Arendt, translated by Harry Zohn, 217–251. New York: Schocken Books, 1968.
Caswell, Michelle. “Archiving the unspeakable : Silence, memory, and the photographic record in Cambodia.” University of Wisconsin Press. 2014
Stanford, Emma. “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates.” In The Routledge Companion to Digital Humanities and Art History, 1st ed., edited by Kathryn Brown. Routledge, 2020. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429505188-19.

Digital Surrogates: From Family Photos to Art Historical Research

From left to right: Brigid Hynes-Cherin, Peter Hynes, Arleen Hynes, and Timothy John Hynes

Week two: 8/25/2026

“The nature of the gap between original and surrogate may change as technology improves, but it can never be entirely closed. In fact, the strengths of digital surrogates lie in their differences: their versatility, their independence from time and place, their potential for creative
interaction.” — Emma Stanford in “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates”

Any museum professional, archivist, or librarian will be able to recognize the significance of digitization, or “digital surrogates,” to the field today. Immense resources, labor, and time have already been dedicated to the digitization of all manner of documents and it’s unlikely that demand for such projects will stop soon. From an accessibility and preservation standpoint, the benefit to a digitized archive is readily apparent. Information held on physical documents can now be preserved where it otherwise might have been at risk of damage or degradation. People from across the globe can now view documents and artifacts held at archives, libraries, and museums, so long as they have access to the internet. There are so many more benefits to well-done digitization projects, like the potential to easily transcribe and translate digitized documents with OCR.

From The Georgia O’Keeffe Museum’s Access O’Keeffe, a comprehensive digital archive which compiles high quality scans of O’Keeffe’s paintings, photographs, letters, and other archival documents. While I was an intern at the O’Keeffe museum, the lead archivist and librarians were still collaborating to make this project a success. The resulting digital interface is easily searchable, with a sophisticated system that allows users to search from a number of tags generated from metadata.

Of course, it is worth interrogating any technology or methodology used by archivists and art historians, particularly when so many resources are directed their way (at times, at the risk of other kinds of projects). In “A Field Guide to Digital Surrogates: Evaluating and Contextualizing a Rapidly Changing Resource,” scholar Emma Stanford outlines the long history of “surrogates” (or, images of art objects) as an essential resource to art historians, while also making a close evaluation of all the complications and pitfalls that this populate this practice in the digital age. Institutional structures, and failings, account for many of these—for example, it is impossible for most institutions to digitize all of their archives, leaving the decision of which objects and documents should be digitized as a curatorial one, and therefore impacted by many of the same factors that continuously shape curatorial decisions. In the case of the Bodleian Libraries at the University of Oxford, this meant that more manuscripts were digitized according to what interested big donors. Even on a smaller scale, editing through omission is one huge way that digitization can distort documents. Stanford points out a number of examples: long manuscripts which only have a few “important” pages digitized, how digitized images often crop the objects and documents they capture, or the inability of photography to capture the tactility of objects and papers.

In reality, so many of the issues that plague digitization efforts have to do with funding and labor, even though Stanford does not always acknowledge this outright. What archives and museums can actually afford to have a lengthy and costly digitization project depends largely on which institutions have funding, which is largely dependent on complex socio-economic factors. There is also the question of usability and access once the archives are actually digitized. As lengthy a process that scanning and archiving digitized documents can be, designing the interfaces through which users access these documents is just as extensive. The ability (or inability) to search for accurately described objects is at the center of what makes a digitized archived accessible (or not). Ideally, each archive would be able to provide extensive tags for objects, and would reliably be able search from the metadata of objects, but this is often not the case. When I designed a digital archive in Omeka for a collection at my undergraduate university, I was certainly not leaving detailed tags for each item. I was the only research assistant working on the project and I simply did not have time, nor was I being paid enough, to make the archive as accessible and searchable as I would have liked it to be.

From my own work as a digital art historian, making archives accessible to the public. https://utctlarchive.org/

Of the above issues with digitization efforts, most are somewhat solvable given enough time and money. There’s one issue that remains genuinely irreconcilable: that a digital surrogate will never be able to capture the physical object in its entirety. Art historians know this well, which is why they often advise students to see works of art in person if at all possible. Stanford believes that rather than being a weakness, the inherent difference of a digital surrogate can be a strength:

“In fact, the strengths of digital surrogates lie in their differences: their versatility, their independence from time and place, their potential for creative interaction. The most effective digital surrogates leverage these traits.” (Stanford, 211).

Recently, I have been able to see these strengths with a newfound emotional potency. My cousin and I are currently embarking on a digitization project for my late Aunt Brigid’s family and travel photos, of which there are thousands. Such a project is a serious archival task, but it’s allowed me to view the work of digitization through new eyes, outside the confines of my professional life. I have a large family (21 first cousins), and I can feel how much it means to everyone to have these images of loved ones, so many of whom have passed, accessible and preserved for future generations.

While nothing can replace the affective experience of holding one of these photographs in your hands, this project can open up new opportunities for family members to see their history where otherwise we might have to wait for another family reunion, wedding, or funeral to view them. When I approach this topic from a critical art historical perspective, I see many of the gaps and failures of digital surrogates as a sign to be wary of them. However, this project has given me assurance of the real-life significance of digitization. Whether or not it’s apparent in the moment, you never know the importance digital surrogates might hold to a researcher or a private individual.

Ultimately, the project of digitization is an important and worthwhile one, but it’s equally important to consider the labor of museum professionals, interns, and volunteers, many of whom may be victim to the exploitative labor practices of a field that so often lacks the money and resources to back otherwise worthy ambitions. It is with this institutional structure in mind that we could continue to acknowledge the limitations of digitization, while advocating for the laborers doing their best to surmount them.

Paul B. Jaskot’s “Digital Art History as the Social History of Art” and the potential for digital storytelling through games

Paul B. Jaskot’s “Digital Art History as the Social History of Art: Towards the Disciplinary Relevance of Digital Methods” questions not only what research questions are best suited for examination using computational tools but what art history itself is. By placing digital art history in the heritage of social art history, Jaskot presents digital art history as capable of changing the art history field like the interventions of feminist and Marxist critiques that came before it. Digital art history is capable of this change by allowing the examination of understudied and noncanonical areas of the field.

The situating of digital art history within social history is not surprising given Jaskot’s background. Jaskot serves as the Co-Director of the Digital Art History & Visual Culture Research Lab at Duke University. His research centers on architecture and Nazi Germany. His projects primarily use GIS to question assumptions about construction and modernism in the era.

One of the more surprising aspects of Jaskot’s article for me was his expansive definition of social art history. Jaskot acknowledges the historical importance of Marxism and feminism and other -isms in reinvigorating art history towards previously unexamined artworks and ideas, but ultimately presents social art history as any approach that treats art and society as deeply interconnected. That relationship is the backbone and focus of social art history. As someone who does not generally consider themselves a social art historian since I rarely use specific identity or political lens, this definition made me reconsider my assessment of my work. My research and projects are often specifically focused on the relational aspect of art and society, mainly understudied areas of video game culture. Even outside that niche, I have an investigative bend in research (likely from growing up watching so much Law & Order as a kid that I played assistant district attorney the way other kids played house). Investigation is about what lives in the cracks of assumptions and following threads of connection to find new truths.

Jaskot also breaks down four of the most common methods used in digital art history: digital storytelling, text analysis, network analysis, and spatial analysis. Jaskot calls out network and spatial analysis as the most used and most fitted to art historical research (as of 2019 when the article was written). This assessment is because Jaskot focuses on large scale projects as the most fertile ground for any type of digital art history. Jaskot is correct that some illuminating projects have used digital art history tools to see areas that would be very difficult to examine without the distance viewing digital art history methods can provide. Network analysis and geographic mapping certainly can work well to preserve large scale complexity alongside a point of view and thesis.

I would be interested to know how Jaskot feels about more recent digital art history projects that use the same tools to look closer than traditional close looking. These projects present a microscopic version of close looking when compared to the space telescope version of distance viewing Jaskot focuses on in the article. One that came to my mind immediately is the presentation of historical research in video games like Pentiment.

Spoiler note: Pentiment – Examples come from interactions that can happen in the first hour or so of the game. I do not touch on the central plot.

Pentiment by Obsidian Entertainment released in 2022, but it’s status in academic research has only continued to grow in the years between then and now (2026). A point-and-click mystery set in Upper Bavaria in the 16th century, Pentiment is extraordinarily well researched. While series like Assassin’s Creed use extensive research in their creation, they often present this research primarily as world building or in objective sounding codex entries that the player can access in the menu. Pentiment embeds the research across the game at all levels. When picking where the player character, a journeyman manuscript illuminator named Andreas, previously studied, you are given the options of Italy, Basel, or Flanders. Each option provides unique dialogue and skills grounded in the history of those places, but also shows how people of different social classes in a small Alpine village conceptualized those places through specific interactions with Andreas.

The art style of Pentiment is also vital to how the game shares insights into perceptions of status, education, and technological progress. Different characters “speak” (via text bubble) in different lettering styles based on Andreas perception of them. The town printer’s speech appears in upside down blocks before reversing into readable script all at once with a clunk. Monks in the scriptorium speak in a flourished ink style that fills in religiously significant words like “Christ” in red after the rest of the text is written. This was a practice I had no idea existed until I search online to see why the script behaved that way.

Pentiment takes this digital narrative presentation beyond research and into a ludic thesis. There are two notable moments early in the game that showed how a ludic thesis could work that stood out to me.

The first moment is when Andreas discovers that a local shepherd is much more well-read then he thought. The shepherd’s speech rewrites itself from a messy illiterate script used for all the peasants to the clear measured text of the academics and educated. The lettering change subtly communicates how status and education worked in the background of all interactions at the time. The second moment is when retrieving books for the Sister who runs the abbey library. As she discusses the books with Andreas, they enter into the books themselves. Here, she has the freedom to explain the lack of choice for women in their lives. She focuses on how this lack of choice is visible in the treatment of the female characters in the books. Women are presented as inherently wicked or only present to suffer for a male character’s benefit regardless of the books being bawdy popular tales, classical texts, or religious allegory.

As the player experiences these moments as Andreas, there is a clear imperative to move beyond enjoyment of the historical setting to reflection on the perspectives about status, equality, progress, and justice that are raised. Despite not explicitly presenting as digital art history, this expansion of purpose makes Pentiment digital social art history. By using digital storytelling, the creators of Pentiment relinquish some control and clarity of their arguments in favor of allowing the player a much closer look than would be possible normally. The player is able to actually control an artist in the time period and choose how to confront the issues raised in game. Despite how the player decides to play Andreas, the reactions of the other characters and the art choices show the clear point of view and arguments being made. It will be interesting to see how new games approach digital storytelling as more works inspired by Pentiment are released. I also wonder if the game studies practice of presenting research in both traditional modes of scholarship and non-tradition modes like game design will expand to other fields).

A First Dive into Digital Art History

This post is a log of first exploration in digital art history. It’s a methodology which feels foreign in that I’ve never called my research skills “digital,” but familiar in that I have always conducted research with the help of online databases and resources. This is what I thought when I first heard the term, thinking it was the use of online tools and databases to conduct art-based research. And while digital sites are the tools for conducting digital art history, the reason for the methodology lies in the new design for scholarship digital forms inspire, which in turn generate new perspectives for reading history. Unpacking the community, material implications, and progressive futures digital tools make possible for research is the topic of this post.

Digital art history, by my understanding, is a term which refers to digitized networks, often activated by contemporary technologies, which invite new methods of critical engagement for historians studying art. The importance of how we critically engage with art using digital tools varies dependent on the goal of its praxis. In “The Digital Transformation of Art History,” digital humanist Harald Klinke recognized digital art history as built atop the same foundation art history has always relied on: data. He interprets our effort to describe, compare, and contextualize art objects as a from of visual data, which we record through publication. Klinke sees the use of computers, which can process large quantities of data with more accuracy and efficiency, to be a better model for visualizing and translating large swathes of data for interpretation. Also known as “distance viewing,” better processing broadens the perspectives of researchers who reorganize their interpretations of individual artists or objects in context with a larger number of data points.

While Klinke thinks back before the digital age, Jaskot thinks forward to understand how digital tools reform our interpretations of history, as well as our social relationship to art objects. In “Digital Art History as the Social History of Art,” Jaskot argues for the use of digital tools as a method for unsettling an author’s bias for what they interpret an object to mean in its social context. Unlike the limited viewpoint of human scholars, digital tools visualize without biased for symmetry or organization, balancing, “aspects of that very tension between uniformity and chaos.” The ability of digital tools to present the bigger picture engages art with audiences and ideas beyond even the scope of its intended use and maker.

This material affect, linked through digital networks, is also a concern of art historian Alison Langmead’s. She cites slides as reproduction of original artwork, then states in “Art and Architectural History and the Performative, Mindful Practice of the Digital Humanities:” “Representation is a form of interpretation and remediation, from the framing chosen, to the color balance used, to the precise technology selected. It is not a neutral act; it is materially transformative.” Indeed, our continued distance from the physical art object paired with our conflation of the image as equal to the object positions digital tools with the potential to expand or collapse our understanding of what the art object is. Additionally, Langmead sees the future of art history as a collaborative effort, citing the end of the slides library as the beginning of isolation for working on research. She sees the public yet unfinished nature of digital art historical projects as a way forward, producing knowledge, “not because it is heading towards a conclusion, but because it will always be in a state of creation and enactment.”

The ulitimate path goal that all three authors see for digital art history is public collaboration. While I have no experience participating in digital art projects, I can speak on the transformative path of art and educational channels thriving across the internet for years. Growing up as a teen on the internet, my first introduction to visual analysis was taught through educational YouTubers, who created long essays on media relevant to my interests. Such accessible content introduced me to why art history is important, and opened my participation in larger dialogue on the art through slides. Both digital databases and online communities are collaborative efforts to extend knowledge beyond oneself. And unlike digital communities built around an individual creator or story, digital art history’s biggest challenge is its retention. As touched on in class, many computer programs shut down due to low user counts or profits. These retention issues which may be aided by stepping outside of archivist projects to learn both about digital educational content.

Can you become an art history expert without ever setting foot into a physical museum?

Photograph of Les Demoiselles d’Avignon – Pablo Picasso 1907 – in the Blanchette Hooker Rockefeller Gallery at the MoMA. Photo taken by Katarina Baltisberger, 2026.

Does digital art history substitute the need for art tourism?

I recently took a trip to the Museum of Modern Art in New York City, a museum that is six floors of some of the best-known artworks in the canon of Western Modern art. Virtually every gallery had a work of art that I had either studied extensively or a work by an artist I have studied extensively. One of the highlights of the collection is Pablo Picasso’s Les Demoiselles d’Avignon, a large-scale painting that revolutionized depictions of the human form through a distinct and developing Modern subject. The painting has established a reputation as emblematic of several converging art movements that emerged from the early 20th century that solidified Les Demoiselles as one of Picasso’s most analyzed works of art. It is an essential work of art to study in university level art history courses; I personally have studied the work in multiple classes. So, when I finally saw Les Demoiselles in person for the first time, I found that I had very little left to engage with.

In The Digital Transformation of Art History, a chapter from the 2020 book Companion to Digital Humanities and Art History – Harald Klinke explores the notion of “distant viewing” (p.34). Alois Riegl coined the term in 1897/8 – originally Fernsicht – to distinguish how our modes of viewing are altered based on our physical proximity to a work of art. When up close to a painting, we can study and understand that the work is made of brushstrokes and, in turn, when far away from a painting, we can employ methodological study the broader work of art. This framework was developed assuming the viewer would be physically in front of a work of art, so, the question is, how do digital renderings of art change our modes of viewing?

The field of art history began in grand tours and flaneur style connoisseurship. Art pilgrimages remain the peak to any art historical research today (otherwise, why would we set departmental travel funds aside for students wanting to see researched works in person?). Yet, for me with Les Demoiselles, I felt that the MoMA had done sufficient work in producing digital renderings of the painting that I as a viewer and student had enough visual information to study the work of art through digital-born distant viewing. I can admit, I am not a Picasso scholar, but I am a Modernist, and in that moment, I felt surprised that I extracted very little from my close viewing experience with Les Demoiselles. So, does this mean that museums are obsolete? Do we even need to go see works of art in person at all if their digital stand-in counterparts do the job? I’d even ask one question further: hypothetically, could you become an art history expert without ever setting foot into a physical museum?

Klinke counters these questions by posing specific difficulties of relying on digital-only modes of viewing. As he sees it, our current systems of digital viewing do not serve as complete enough of platforms to support research questions (p.36). The data associated with works of art could be irrelevant, insufficient, and invalid. Their visualizations only tell part of the story behind the work and lack distinct interactivity. Why would a researcher have to travel to the MoMA to see Les Demoiselles d’Avignon when they could just go online and look up an image of it themselves? Digital art history aims to do what conventional art history cannot – it allows equal access. Yet, as a consequence of doing so, Klinke observes that art historical research is largely conducted alone. Klinke argues that digital art history should not replace conventional methods of art history and should serve as an extension of traditional approaches that enhances and deepens understanding.

Where spaces like museums, libraries, and classrooms may feel obsolete now that you can just look up the same information online, digital spaces do not allow the same level of collaborative communication. Distant viewing when done alone without contextual information is just looking. Collaboration through learning visual and digital literacy skills is the key to true art historical understanding. My viewing experience of seeing Les Demoiselles at the museum was not deeply stimulating, but this is because I have already done so much collaborative visual learning on the painting in the classroom. While I am still unsure if someone could become an expert in art history without ever setting foot into an art museum, I do feel strongly that someone cannot become an expert in art history by themselves. In creating this blog, here is my own kind of attempt at engaging in digital art history through a more social internet. I put my thoughts into the world with hopes that it creates collaborative and productive art historical discussion.

« Older posts Newer posts »